After the two-and-a-half hour interview, Drake indicated he would return back to discuss the case more, but he never did. But over the years there was even more strange behavior, moments that, authorities believe add up to circumstantial evidence. It's emotional. Her whereabouts remained a mystery for more than 35 years until her remains were discovered in 2019. Barr did attest to his behavior being unusual when he decided to run for office on multiple occasions, because of his lack of experience. Jim and Gloria Matthews had moved to Greeley just six years earlier, to raise their young daughters Jennifer and Jonelle. Pankey is a representative of the Republican Party. However, no DNA evidence was extracted from it, making the evidence against Pankey circumstantial. Colorado courts do not have an online records system, so the Statesman on Thursday requested via U.S. mail copies of Pankeys criminal charges in Weld County. The best home improvement jobs deserve the best materials. They were found just outside the house. On the night Jonelle went missing, Pankey said, he was home with his then-wife. but he took her he shot her. And then on July 23, 2019, nearly 35 years after Jonelle's disappearance, police finally had that breaking news to share. Before Olson took the stand, he was only given one six-paged police report from his investigation into Drake. He had a friendship with a younger girl, but Yost said she didnt believe there was anything romantic between the two. Pankeys father believed a womans place was in the home, women had to obey her husband and other more traditional ideas of marriage. Richard Schlesinger: What do you think happened to your sister? I wouldn't recommend it to anyone. of course, you know, you think that's terrible, but lots of kids go missing, you know. Anthony Viorst: That is arguably the one piece of evidence that arguably ties Mr. Pankey to the crime. Darla Jentzsch: It was such a mystery, this whole thing happened. LOCAL NEWS REPORT: Jonelle Matthews will turn 13 in two weeks. Over the phone, Pankey said he was a pastor from a Baptist church. Pankeys relationship with Christy was not pleasant either, Hicks said. Mayor John Gates: My assignment that night was going around the neighborhood, knocking on doors asking them if they had seen or heard anything suspicious that evening. Sakulenzki confirmed she reached out to the Federal Bureau of Investigation in 2009 about Pankey, and to the Greeley Police Department in 2019. She described being forced to listen to news accounts about Jonelle's disappearance, and she told jurors about finding a piece of paper in Pankey's trash. Richard Schlesinger: Arguably? In 1999 he told the Idaho Supreme Court, after a conviction for once again causing a scene in a bank, that the conviction which was dismissed years later was in part an "attempt to force" him "to become an informant" in Jonelle's disappearance. He doesnt talk much about his mother, but generally gives the impression that he was raised in a very religious family. Jonelle became one of the first missing children whose photo appeared on milk cartons across America. Anthony Viorst: He argued with a bank teller and the police were called. This story was originally published September 13, In September 2001, Hicks filed for divorce from Pankey. By Chelsea Narvaez is the associate producer. Her remains were discovered on July 24, 2019, and the trial for her murder began. The Twin Falls Police Department verified Thursday that it had executed the warrant on Wednesday, Sept. 4, at Pankeys condo in the 300 block of Elm Street North. And I had a 5-year-old son. He's had periodic sort of spats with people because he is an irascible, prickly guy. At first, he thought Jonelle was at a friend's house, but after calling around and waiting about a half hour to an hour, Jim says he called police. He had abducted her on Dec 20th, 1984 from her home after she came home from a Christmas concert. Idaho Falls news, Rexburg news, Pocatello news, East Idaho news, Idaho news, education news, crime news, good news, business news, entertainment news, Feel Good Friday and more. On November 2, 2021, the jurors got the case. The best home improvement jobs deserve the best materials. Once back in Greeley, she says Pankey drove right past their house, straight to the grocery store, where he made her buy the local papers and search for news about Jonelle. He said he moved to Greeley in 1973. Viorst believed it was possible for Drake to have left directly after the show ended to commit the crimes against Jonelle. Jim Matthews: Hopefully we will know the scenario of what happened that night. On Monday, Hicks testified Pankey was less happy with his job when Ross became his boss at the 7 Up Bottling Company, especially after he was let go from his position over a legal battle Pankey started. Jim Matthews: She was interested in any kind of performing thing. Tuesday, Hicks testified that a day before his memorial service, she witnessed a bizarre moment. STEVE PANKEY [to KMVT]: I contacted the Fort Collins FBI office. Hicks also stated in her testimony that Pankey banned radio, TV and news from their household around the time Jonelle went missing. / CBS News, [This story previously aired on January 8, 2022. They never released the information about the rake. Richard Schlesinger: Was Pankey questioned at all in the early days of this investigation? They also testified this information was never made public. Kevin Schneider: Yes, he did. The detectives then left. He said she lived across the street from his mothers home, according to Daviets testimony. In a matter of days, the search was all over the news, but not because police were talking. Angela Hicks says her then-husband came home and seemingly out of the blue, announced they were leaving on that trip to California and they were leaving quickly. Wells argued Al Dominguez, the district attorney of Weld County during that time, previously testified he never touched nor came across Jonelles case. The most Pankey families were found in USA in 1880. During her testimony, she said she only saw pornography on his computer one time, and only saw women. (CBS4) -- A child's disappearance from Greeley in 1984 went cold, until the remains of Jonelle Matthews were found in July 2019. Jim Matthews: You have to go on with life. Jim Matthews: Yeah, right out of my garage. On October 12, 2020 Steven Pankey was arrested for the nearly 35-year-old kidnapping and murder of 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews. Who is Stephen Banke Son Karl Banke? His father was a Youth for Christ leader, and Pankey claimedthat he came from a family with a long history of Rochelle Davy, formerly known as Rochelle Baxley, was with Jonelle Matthews on the bus the night she disappeared. "48 Hours" interviewed Pankey's attorney Anthony Viorst as he was preparing for trial. He just does, for whatever reason. A Ryan Horsley: Yeah. Hicks said she found torn-up paper about Jonelle in the trash can. Hicks talked to officers about her husbands behavior and actions after Jonelle went missing, including the fact that he was aware of evidence from the crime scene that was not public knowledge. Brett Kavanaugh, associate justice of the US's Supreme Court, has been serving in th Former CIA officer Matt Castelli is running for Congress in the NY-21 district. That was our sign that she made it inside and everything's fine. And then he buried her and went on with his life. Jordan Kinsey, Elizabeth Caholo and Lauren A. Officers told Hicks that Pankey was the one who claimed to have information involving Jonelles disappearance but refused to give the police anything until they gave him immunity, she said. Ryan Horsley: Out of the blue he began, um, purchasing firearms and later found out that Greeley Police Department had been contacting him regarding this murder investigation. Mayor John Gates: The most strong evidence to me is the way Mr. Pankey conducted himself from the time this happened up until his indictment. It was updated on August 6.]. In 2008, he thought about running in Twin Falls, where he went to church with Ryan Horsley, a political consultant. at their state convention, he claimed that they tried to do an exorcism on him. The red-orange car was allegedly seen by Jonelle and her friend on the bus heading back from the choir concert on Dec. 20, 1984. WebSteve Pankey and Angela Hicks' son, Carl, was murdered in 2008. Hicks had no recollection of Pankey being away the night Jonelle went missing or that night being different from other nights since her husband would come home anytime between 4-11 p.m. on most days, Hicks told Viorst. There were no fingerprints and if there was DNA, law enforcement was still several years from being able to analyze it. Before interviewing Drake on the record, Olson spoke with Drake, and he revealed he had knowledge about raked-over shoe prints in the backyard of the Matthews home the night Jonelle went missing. Gloria Matthews: Everywhere we went I was always looking for her I always had hope that I would find her. Anthony Viorst: I can't answer that because I can't get into his head but, but I do think it's a combination of sort of obsessive-compulsive behavior and you know, perhaps even mental illness. JUDGE TIMOTHY KERNS: Has the jury reached a unanimous verdict on count number four? The presentation confirmed there was no probable cause to bring the case to prosecution due to a lack of evidence, Olson said. I just wanted to not be married to him anymore, she said. Authorities searched a home in Twin Falls, Idaho. Gloria Matthews: We are going to know that she was murdered [crying]. Thats why its so important to That great looking new building in Wiggins? He was surprised when they didnt. And on October 13, 2021, a jury was seated and ready to hear the case. The ex-wife of Steve Pankey, the man accused of killing 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews in 1984, testified in his murder trial Monday and Tuesday. As per reports, the 14-year-old was kidnapped and reportedly killed somewhere in Greeley, Colorado. Pankey said he had gone to church with many people who knew Jonelle Matthews family, but he did not. On those other counts, the actual murder charges, the jury deadlocked and could not come to a unanimous verdict. The selection changes often, but if you love good Buying or selling a home is the largest financial investment most people ever make. She said a very emotional Pankey walked up Oct. 18When Steve Pankey's son was murdered in 2008, his ex-wife heard him say in front of the urn, "I hope God didn't allow this to happen because of Jonelle Matthews." Angela Hicks, Pankey's former spouse, took the stand for her second day of testimony Monday morning. One of the star witnesses in this case, Steven Pankey's ex-wife Angela Hicks, testified about what she says she witnessed while married to Pankey. The day before the In his closing argument, Viorst, who's a lawyer, not a psychiatrist, raised serious questions about his client's mental health. How Many Games Are Played In The First Round Of The NHL Playoffs. Deanna Ross: As a community, it rocked Greeley. Here we have explained his remarkable political journey after serving his country and community as a responsible officer. But just five days before Christmas, Greeley learned it could not hide from evil. She said she has been around Pankey only a handful of times, the last time being the memorial service for Carl. She reported seeing Drake sit in his vehicle for a while, as if he was staring at something. At trial, Viorst told the jury that Pankey was a true-crime junkie. ANTHONY VIORST: Norris Drake, Ladies and gentlemen, knew that the footprints were raked. Several reports say that he endured the death of his son but the details are unconfirmed. Of course, the prosecution also has Pankey's own words. Prior to appearing in court Wednesday, Yost informed Viorst she had no desire to testify and felt like she didnt have anything to say that would make a difference in this case. I believed, at the time, he might have involvement, Olson said. At least they did until that night December 20. DA MICHAEL ROURKE: The evidence in this case will prove that the defendant is guilty of murder in the first degree and second-degree kidnapping. The man, who tried to threaten Justice Brett Kavanaugh with his life, was arrested with the joint efforts of the U.S. There was one occasion where he made comments about how attractive younger girls were at the pool. That was about 8 p.m. Deanna Ross: Jonelle needed a ride home so she hopped in our truck and we took her home. After being charged, he left the position. Both were members of the Sunny View Church of the Nazarene and friends to the Matthews family, who had also attended the church. Pankeys eldest son has no recollection of this ban and remembers watching TV with his parents, he said during his short time on the stand. At the time, Pankey and his former wife lived about 2 miles away. Gloria was working at a restaurant. Richard Schlesinger: Were you a close family? He was a person who sure was interested in the case. STEVE PANKEY [Idaho Statesman political ad]: I'm one of the people who wants to represent you. There were two campaigns for governor, one for municipal council, one for lieutenant governor and three runs for county sheriff. Jim Matthews: The Rescue Jonelle Committee made all kinds of things happen. Greeley Mayor and former police officer John Gates knew Steven Pankey, and says he was not considered a person of interest in the early days when Jonelle first disappeared. And I heard on the car radio that a girl was missing from Greeley, Colorado. Everything to know about his ex-wife and son. Additionally, she contacted friends with the Englewood police about the case a few weeks after her disappearance. Pankeys youngest son, Carl, a 20-year-old college student, was shot and killed by his girlfriend in 2008 in Phoenix. In 2020, Steven Pankey, who says he never met Jonelle, was charged with murder after repeatedly making public statements that inserted him into the case, including drawing up a list of persons of interest with his own name on it. GREELEY, CO OCTOBER 13: Murder suspect Steven Pankey, right, listens to testimony on the first day of his trial at Weld County District Court on October 13, 2020 in The Statesman could not immediately verify that. The rake came, "right out of my garage," Jim Matthews told "48 Hours.". He was criminally charged, but the charge was later dismissed by prosecutors. Jonelles case dates back to Dec. 20, 1984, when the young girl attended a school choir concert, received a ride home from her friends father and returned to an unoccupied home. Viorst and Hicks discussed Pankeys anti-establishment views, believing law enforcement was actively out to get him and having occasional run-ins with the police. The selection changes often, but if you love good Buying or selling a home is the largest financial investment most people ever make. Richard Schlesinger: Where was he the night Jonelle Matthews disappeared? Richard Schlesinger: I'm sorry, did you say an exorcism? It builds a really, really strong circumstantial case, in my mind. He even mentioned them in a 2019 conversation, with investigators. Their son, Carl, was murdered in Phoenix in 2008. yes, I remember meeting him. Richard Schlesinger: What was it like for you to be considered a suspect in your daughter's disappearance? The other counts were were far more complex than that, in my opinion. The big thing in policing now is DNA. Pankey was on the stand for two days giving testimony that was often rambling and hard to follow, and sometimes head-scratching. But boy, just the floodgates opened up for both of us. Anthony Viorst: Mr. Pankey likes to talk. Richard Schlesinger: The problem is there's no physical evidence. The case drew national attention. Daviet recalls sleeping on the couch right by the front door when Drake arrived home past midnight to go to his room in the basement. During her testimony last week, she stated her and Jonelle allegedly saw an orange-red car that agitated and startled her 12-year-old friend. STEVE PANKEY [to KMVT]: He told me that a cop had contacted him and said that he had a body he wanted to be buried. Around that same time, Steven Pankey, his young son and his wife, who was pregnant with their second son, also left Greeley. They planned to leave at 5 a.m. the next day for the drive to Big Bear Lake to visit his parents. At the time, Pankey was a youth minister at Sunny View Church of the Nazarene in Greeley. Pankey made an unusual witness in his own defense. ANTHONY VIORST: So that's why there was no struggle, all right? Mayor John Gates: I had met him in about the mid-1970s. On October 12, 2020, police arrested Steven Pankey for kidnapping and first-degree murder. The 71-year-old was a person of interest in the case over the course of three decades. Pankey said two Greeley detectives came to his condo around Aug. 15 and asked to interview him, but he told them that he would speak to them only if his attorney was present. 2021 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. When Drake woke up the next day, he came upstairs and asked if the Daviets had heard about Jonelles disappearance. STEVEN PANKEY A month, three weeks, two months, I don't know, before December. They made headlines. But denied he was obsessed with the news. As currently indicated, Karl Banke was the youngest child of Stephen Banke. What happened? Additionally, there was no mention of Drakes shoe size in Olsons writings, and he couldnt remember the shoe size from memory during his testimony. Afterwards she got a ride home with Deanna Ross and Deanna's father. On the night Jonelle vanished, Drake was unaccounted for for several hours. STEVE PANKEY [to KMVT]: They've got full SWAT gear on. Alleged Chinese spy, Christine Lee's son worked for MP Barry Gardiner and they are not related biologically. He said he won all the trials. But there was no rest for the Matthews. The objections resulted in several sidebars, one about a possible conversation Daviet had with Drake and another conversation she had with Englewood police.